Grading Journals

    Number of entries:

    Excellent (A) Good (B) Adequate (C) Below college level work (D - E)
    Theory and technique Uses psychological theory and terminology accurately and in a sophisticated manner. Is able to apply theory appropriately and accurately. Journal looks at the implications of the theory, not all of which are discussed in the book or class. Uses theory in rigid manner. Terms are used accurately, but theory only describes rather than lending insight into person's behavior or motivation. Journal is a good description of theory in the book, but does not include synthesis or original thinking. Theory is used in a superficial manner, with some minor mistakes in application. Journal is a weak description of theory in the book. Theory does not apply to person/situation or is used inappropriately.
    Insight Insightful about self/other/theory. Recognizes context and exceptions. It makes me go Wow! Journal is somewhat insightful, but not as much as I would have wished. You tease rather than satisfy! Journal does not help the reader understand the self/other/theory observed. Journal is off-track in its conclusions.
    Divergent thinking Approaches issue from multiple viewpoints (e.g., views problem from multiple vantages, recognizes multiple contributions to issues, or sees pros and cons of theory). Approaches problem well, but from only one or two viewpoints. Issue is approached weakly from a single vantage. Issue is approached poorly from a single vantage.
    Respectful and empathic approach Behavior is described in strength-based rather than judgmental manner. Context is given for observations (e.g., recent death of partner, a court-ordered interview, a poor night's sleep etc.). Journal is respectful of the person. Journal is neither strength-based nor really judgmental, but tends to focus more on problems and ignore strengths. Journal is somewhat judgmental. Context for behavior may be overlooked. If you are looking at someone else, I have a difficult time understanding him or her based on your description. Journal is judgmental. Self/other/theory is not approached in an empathic manner.

    University / Department / Home / Skills / After graduation / Schools / Syllabi

    Page by jms
    URL= http://psy1.clarion.edu/jms/intCHandoutgr.html

    Last modified January 12, 2004.