Unit on Psychoanalysis
Slide 1: Psychoanalysis
Sigmund Freud, Anna Freud, Karen Horney, Carl Jung, Alfred Adler, and many
others
Slide 2: Some definitions
-
Psychoanalysis. Based on Freud's ideas, generally emphasizing the
importance of the id and superego as well as sexual impulses.
-
Psychodynamic approaches. Based on ideas of Freud's followers, although
often significantly diverging from Freud. Often emphasizing the ego and
impulses other than sex.
Slide 3: Psychoanalysis' bad rap
-
Sexually obsessed.
Psychoanalysis is not so much a question of science as a matter
of taste, Dr. Freud being an artist who lives in the fairyland of dreams
among the ogres of perverted sex. -Cattell (1926)
-
Sexist. Penis envy and the inferiority of female superego
-But remember the times...
-
Racist. Aimed at YAVIS client.
-Again, remember the times. Only recently have cultural differences
in preferences for therapies beenacknowledged.
-
Aimed at wealthy. Very long treatment periods.
-Only recently has therapy been available to everyone.
-
Monolithic. Anything but!
-
Simplistic. Perhaps because of the difficulty in summarizing very
complicated ideas.
-
Pessimistic view of the world.
Freud saw people as foolish and weak and often self-deluded. The
more empathic theories see people as basically good, but injured, and for
a lot of us, this is easier to swallow. -Peter Kramer (1998)
-
Unscientific and untestable.
But this procedure of free association and so on is queer, because
Freud never shows how we know where to stop -- where is the right solution.
-Ludwig Wittgenstein (1942)
Slide 4: Many of these complaints have
validity. Why has psychoanalysis continued to be a very influential set
of ideas?
Slide 5: Why psychoanalysis?
[Freud is] generally recognized as a figure of immense cultural importance.
He changed the way we understand drama, history, biography, and he gave
us a whole new picture of how a person becomes a person. He unified dreams,
fantasies, fairy tales and myths -- and from many different cultures around
the world. -Harold Blum (1988)
Slide 6: What does psychoanalysis contribute
to modern therapies?
-
Our awareness is incomplete.
Slide 7: What is conscious?
-
Ego. The reality oriented, problem solving part of person.
Slide 8: What else is there?
-
Id. Our unconscious, unacceptable impulses.
-
Superego.
Slide 9:
Freud sees us as basically bad beings who must be controlled by superego.
Contrast this view with Rogers'.
Slide 10: These are kept from us by defense
mechanisms
-
Repression. Pushes from awareness. Other defense mechanisms are
variations on this.
-
Projection. Sees unacceptable feelings in others
-
Reaction formation. Transforms unacceptable feelings to polar opposite.
-
Intellectualization. Cuts off feelings and focuses on thoughts.
-
Sublimation. Transforms impulse into socially acceptable behavior.
Slide 11:
All defense mechanisms distort reality and ultimately prevent us from coping
with the world adaptively.
Slide 12: What does psychoanalysis contribute
to modern therapies?
-
Our awareness is incomplete.
-
We are affected by unconscious material.
-
Present is affected by the past.
-
Increasing insight is important and useful.
-
Emotional events and flashbacks have meaning.
-
The meaning of mental events may not be what it seems on the surface.
Slide 13: Our fantasies, wishes, desires can
cause guilt and anxiety
We can:
-
Resolve the conflict openly, or
-
Use a defense mechanism (which resolves the problem in the short-term,
but increases it over the long-term)
-
Therefore the focus is on insight and adaptive coping mechanisms...
Slide 14: What if we remove symptom without
insight?
-
Psychoanalytic view: Symptom substitution
-
Behavioral view: No more symptom! No new symptom!
-
Evidence supports the behaviorists' viewpoint.
Slide 15: Can we address problem directly?
No.
-
We're not directly aware of the problem. (Remember the iceberg?)
-
We'll defend against increasing awareness directly.
Slide 16: What can we do instead?
Use free association and techniques based on it:
-
Dream analysis
-
Transference. Client's nonreality-oriented perception of therapist.
-
Countertransference. Therapist's nonreality-oriented perception
of client.
-
Resistance. Avoidance of therapeutic tasks.
-
Humor
-
Mistakes.
-Everything is grist for the mill!
Slide 17: Nature of therapeutic relationship
Therapy should be:
-
Insight-oriented. Postpone making changes until you understand their
meaning.
Therapist should:
-
Take neutral stance to foster the transference.
-
Be directive. The therapist is the expert.
Page by jms
URL= http://psy1.clarion.edu/jms/cptpsychanalysispp.html
Last modified October 8, 2001.